How Climate and Cellar Shape a Grape

Summary

Chardonnay and the three Bordeaux reds

Chardonnay has modest aromas of its own, so the climate and the cellar show in the glass. An unoaked Chablis and a warm-climate, barrel-fermented California Chardonnay differ in alcohol, acidity, fruit and butter. Four causes explain the gap: climate, the vessel (steel or oak), malolactic conversion and lees stirring. The chapter ends this part with a side-by-side tasting exercise.

Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc and Merlot are related, and Cabernet Franc is a parent of the other two. Berry size and skin thickness explain much of their tannin and body. The green pepper note comes from pyrazines, and whether it reads as a flaw depends on how much is present and whether the tannin is ripe. The Left Bank and Right Bank of Bordeaux grow different blends because gravel and clay suit different grapes. The chapter closes the section with what cheap bottles of each grape tend to taste like.

Why Willamette Valley favors Chardonnay over Cabernet

David Lett brought Chardonnay cuttings to the valley in the mid-1960s. Early California clones often struggled to ripen, and the Dijon clones that arrived in 1987 and 1988 changed that. From around 2007, producers picked earlier and used less new oak. Technical sheets from The Eyrie Vineyards show moderate alcohol and mostly neutral oak. A James Suckling report praised Oregon Chardonnay, and the valley's Chardonnay acreage doubled between 2014 and 2025.

Cabernet Sauvignon needs more warmth than the valley provides. The chapter explains growing degree days and compares the valley's totals with warmer regions. Oregon's Cabernet grows in the Rogue and Applegate valleys and in Walla Walla.

Ricochet's Pinot blanc and where its grapes come from

Ricochet Wine Co. in McMinnville makes no Chardonnay or Cabernet, but its 2023 Pinot blanc shows the cellar choices from the lesson. The grapes come from Yamhill Valley Vineyards, were whole-cluster pressed, and were fermented in French oak with full malolactic conversion. The chapter also explains how a winery that buys its grapes is limited to what its growers can supply. Ricochet's Syrah, Tempranillo and MRV white blend come from Les Collines Vineyard in warm Walla Walla.

The valley this November

Harvest is finished. Final 2026 tonnage and critics' verdicts on the vintage have not been reported. Willamette Valley Vineyards reported third-quarter results: sales were up, the quarter still showed a net loss, and the winery held a large inventory. The chapter uses this to explain how a winery can grow sales and still lose money while its wine ages unsold. There were no new federal labeling rules and no appellation changes.

Wine Country Thanksgiving runs over two weekends in late November, and Ricochet holds A Very Indie Thanksgiving on November 21 and 22. The chapter suggests tasting Ricochet's Pinot blanc beside another white. Syrah and Grenache come next.


Two grapes in this lesson could hardly behave more differently. Chardonnay is a fairly plain grape. Most of what you taste in a glass of it comes from where it grew and what the winemaker did in the cellar. Cabernet Sauvignon is the opposite kind of grape. It brings its own character with it: thick skins, firm grip and dark fruit, wherever it is planted. Merlot, its close relative, brings softness. Once you see why each grape tastes the way it does, you can read a glass of either one back to the climate and the cellar choices that made it.

After Pinot noir, the grapes unit turns to Chardonnay, then Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc and Merlot, and tasting words you already have, such as malolactic conversion, lees, diacetyl, vanillin and pyrazines, turn up in each of them.

Chardonnay and the Cabernets in the glass

Start with the clearest comparison in white wine: an unoaked Chablis beside a warm-climate California Chardonnay that was fermented in barrels. Both bottles are one hundred percent Chardonnay, yet they read almost like two different grapes. What follows are the typical style descriptions for each, the way wine educators and producers lay them out.

Chablis comes from the northern edge of Burgundy, in France, where the climate is cool. Unoaked Chablis typically smells of green apple, pear, lemon and white flowers. Many tasters also describe a chalky, flinty or salty quality, often called minerality. On the palate the acidity is high and crisp, the body is light to medium, and the alcohol usually sits around twelve to thirteen and a half percent.

The warm, barrel-fermented California style goes the other way on almost every point. The fruit moves to ripe peach, yellow apple, mango and pineapple. On top of that fruit sit butter, vanilla, crème brûlée, toffee, toasted nuts and baking spice. The acidity is softer, closer to medium. The wine feels full, round and creamy in the mouth, and the alcohol commonly runs fourteen to fourteen and a half percent, sometimes up to fifteen.

So the two wines differ by about two percentage points of alcohol, by a clear step in acidity, by fruit that sits in a different part of the orchard, and by a whole layer of butter and vanilla that one has and the other lacks. Now trace each of those differences back to its cause. There are four, and they stack.

The first cause is climate. In a cool place, grapes ripen slowly. They keep more of their natural malic acid, the sharp, green-apple acid we met in the sweetness and acidity lesson, and they build less sugar. Less sugar means less alcohol after fermentation, because yeast turns sugar into alcohol. The fruit flavors stay in the green apple and citrus range. In a warm place, grapes ripen further. Acid drops, sugar rises, the alcohol that sugar will become rises with it, and the fruit shifts toward stone fruit and tropical fruit. That one fact explains the alcohol gap, most of the acid gap and the change from lemon to pineapple.

The second cause is the vessel. Fermenting and aging in stainless steel keeps the grape's own fruit and freshness and adds no wood flavor at all. New oak barrels add flavor. Oak lactones and the toasting of the barrel bring vanilla, caramel, baking spice and smoke. A barrel also lets a tiny amount of air through its wood over months, and that slow contact with oxygen rounds the wine's texture. Chablis is mostly made in steel or old, flavorless barrels. The California style leans on new oak.

The third cause is malolactic conversion. Bacteria, chiefly a species called Oenococcus oeni, turn sharp malic acid into softer lactic acid, the acid in milk. That lowers how acidic the wine tastes, softens how it feels, and can produce diacetyl, the compound that smells of butter. A winemaker who wants a crisp wine can block malolactic conversion. A winemaker who wants a creamy, buttery wine lets it run all the way.

The fourth cause is lees stirring, which the French call bâtonnage. Lees are the dead yeast cells left after fermentation. Stirring them back up through the wine keeps the wine in contact with them, and that adds body, a creamy texture in the middle of the palate, and quiet notes of bread, biscuit or nuts.

Put the four together and you can read the California glass like a recipe. Warm sun gave it ripe tropical fruit, softer acid and more alcohol. New oak gave it vanilla and toast. Full malolactic conversion gave it butter and took the edge off the acid. Lees stirring gave it its thick, creamy middle. Grow the grapes somewhere cool, skip the new oak and the stirring, and you are back near Chablis. Most Chablis still goes through malolactic conversion, but cool-climate fruit starts with so much acid that the wine stays crisp.

That is why Chardonnay is sometimes called a winemaker's grape. Its own aromas are modest, so it shows the hand of the climate and the cellar clearly.

The grape itself comes from Burgundy. It is a natural cross of Pinot noir and an old, rather humble white grape called Gouais blanc. From there it has spread to become one of the most widely planted white grapes in the world. It grows across France, in Burgundy and in Champagne, where it goes into sparkling wine. It grows in California and Oregon, Australia, New Zealand, Chile, Italy and England, and in Austria, where some growers call it Morillon.

What does an ordinary bottle show? Inexpensive supermarket Chardonnay usually comes from vineyards pushed to give big crops. When a vine carries more fruit, each grape tends to carry less flavor, so these wines are less concentrated. Many are fermented or aged in stainless steel tanks with oak chips or oak staves added, which gives a hint of vanilla far more cheaply than a barrel does. The result is either a simple unoaked white or a softly oaked wine with straightforward fruit and mild vanilla. Neither is a fault. They are simply the low-cost version of choices you now know how to name.

If you like, you can test this lesson tonight. Pour small glasses of two ordinary Chardonnays side by side: one labeled unoaked, or a Chablis, and one oaked California bottle. For each glass, note four things. Acid: does your mouth water after you sip? Body: does it feel more like water or more like milk? Fruit: is it apple and lemon, or peach and pineapple? And oak and butter: do you find vanilla, toast or a buttery smell? When the exercise has worked, you can say which wine came from the cooler place and which one went through new oak and malolactic conversion, and you can name the clue in the glass that told you each one. Small pours and a spittoon are normal practice for this kind of comparison.

Now to red wine, and a family of grapes that carries its own character with it.

Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc and Merlot are relatives. Cabernet Franc is the parent of both of the others. Crossed with Sauvignon blanc, it gave Cabernet Sauvignon. Crossed with an old grape called Magdeleine Noire des Charentes, it gave Merlot. So when these three show up together in a blend, as they often do, they are family.

Tell them apart first by the grape itself, because the berry explains most of the wine.

Cabernet Sauvignon has small berries with thick skins. A small berry has more skin for its amount of juice, and the skin is where tannin and color live. That is why Cabernet Sauvignon makes full-bodied wines with high, firm tannin, the drying grip you learned to feel on your gums. It also keeps fairly high acidity. Its flavors run to dark fruit, blackcurrant, which the French call cassis, plus blackberry and black cherry, with cedar, tobacco and a pencil-lead note often called graphite. It buds late and ripens late. That last point matters a great deal for where it can grow, as you will see.

Merlot has larger, thinner-skinned berries. Less skin for the juice means softer tannin, often described as velvety, and its acidity is lower. The body is medium to full, and the flavors run to plum, black cherry, cocoa and mocha. It ripens early, often about two weeks ahead of Cabernet Sauvignon. That makes Merlot the safer grape where autumn is short or cool.

Cabernet Franc is the lighter one of the three. Its skins are thin, and it buds and ripens early in cooler climates. It makes medium-bodied wines with moderate to medium-high tannin, zesty acidity, red fruit and violets, with graphite, tobacco leaf, dried herbs and often a green bell pepper note.

That green pepper smell has a known source. It comes from methoxypyrazines, a kind of pyrazine, the compounds we first met in the lesson on where aromas come from. The main one in these grapes is called isobutyl methoxypyrazine, IBMP for short. People can smell it at astonishingly small amounts, roughly two to sixteen nanograms per liter. A nanogram is a billionth of a gram, so a few nanograms in a liter of wine is a trace you could never weigh at home, yet your nose picks it up. Pyrazines sit in the skins and stems of the whole Bordeaux family. They peak around veraison, when the grapes change color, and then break down in sunlight and warmth. So a cool year, a shaded vine with lots of leaves, a big crop or an early harvest all leave more pyrazine behind. Too much brings green pepper, cut grass or asparagus, and it usually arrives with harsh, unripe tannin. A little can read as a pleasant leafy freshness, especially in Cabernet Franc. Whether green pepper in a glass is a feature or a flaw depends on how much there is and whether the tannin beside it feels ripe.

These three grapes meet most famously in Bordeaux, in southwest France, where they are blended rather than bottled alone. Bordeaux is split by its rivers, and the two sides grow different blends for a reason you can trace to the ground.

On the Left Bank, in places such as the Médoc, Graves and Pessac-Léognan, the soils are deep gravel left by ancient rivers. Gravel drains water fast, which keeps the vines from growing too much leaf. The stones also soak up heat in the day and give it back at night. That extra warmth is what lets late-ripening Cabernet Sauvignon finish ripening there, so the Left Bank's blends are led by Cabernet Sauvignon. They tend toward firm tannin, blackcurrant and cedar, and they are built to age.

On the Right Bank, in Saint-Émilion, Pomerol and Fronsac, the soils are heavier clay and limestone. They are cooler and hold more water. Late Cabernet Sauvignon struggles there, but early-ripening Merlot thrives, often with Cabernet Franc beside it. So Right Bank blends are led by Merlot and tend to be plusher and rounder, with plum and softer tannin.

If you ever set a Left Bank Médoc beside a Right Bank Saint-Émilion or Pomerol, those are the differences the style descriptions lead you to look for: more grip and dark currant on one side, more softness and plum on the other. The grapes explain most of it, and the soil explains why each grape got its own side of the river.

Outside Bordeaux, Cabernet Sauvignon is planted in California, Washington, Australia, Chile and South Africa, and Merlot in California, Washington, Chile, Italy, Australia and New Zealand. At the low end of the price range, these places make large volumes of softer, simpler, straightforwardly fruity wines from both grapes. The tannin is often eased and the fruit pushed forward, so an inexpensive Cabernet can feel much gentler than a Médoc. Cabernet Franc is less common at the cheapest tier. It comes mostly from the Loire Valley in France, from Italy, the United States and South America. An entry-level bottle typically shows medium body, brisk acidity, red fruit and a noticeable leafy or green pepper note. If you meet that pepper note in a cheap Cabernet Franc, you now know what it is and why it is there.

Chardonnay at home, and why Cabernet stays away

The Willamette Valley grows Chardonnay well and Cabernet Sauvignon hardly at all, and the reasons come straight out of the ripening lesson you just heard.

Chardonnay arrived early. In the mid-1960s, David Lett, who went on to found The Eyrie Vineyards, brought Chardonnay cuttings north from the Draper Ranch in St. Helena, California. These were cuttings taken from many vines in a vineyard rather than one selected clone. Other early growers planted a California clone called 108 and Wente clones. Clone 108, a California selection, often struggled to ripen well in Oregon's cool climate, and many early wines were also heavy with new oak. For years Chardonnay stood in Pinot noir's shadow.

The change came with new clones. Dijon clones 76, 95 and 96, selections from Burgundy that ripen earlier, arrived in Oregon in 1987 and 1988. Oregon State University, working with Dr. Raymond Bernard in Burgundy, brought them in, they went through quarantine, and nurseries spread them through the 1990s. A clone, as we said in the Pinot noir lesson, is a cutting line from one chosen vine, so planting clones bred for cool Burgundy suited the valley's short, cool seasons.

The cellar changed too. Beginning around 2007, with the Burgundian consultant Dominique Lafon working in the valley, producers moved toward picking earlier, keeping higher natural acidity and using less new oak. In the terms of this lesson, they stopped making Willamette Chardonnay in the warm, buttery California mold and moved it toward the cool, fresh side.

Producers' own technical sheets show that style. The Eyrie Vineyards' 2019 Chardonnay was aged ninety and a half percent in neutral French oak, the old barrels that add little flavor, at thirteen point oh three percent alcohol. That alcohol sits up with lean Chablis, not with the fourteen-and-a-half-percent California style. Domaine Drouhin Oregon has described a Chardonnay made half in stainless steel and half in French oak, with full malolactic conversion. Walter Scott Wines has described one made with native yeast, forty-five percent new oak, full malolactic conversion and thirteen percent alcohol. Even where these wines use new oak or full malolactic conversion, the alcohol stays moderate and the valley's acid stays high.

Critics have noticed. In February 2026, Courtney Humiston, writing for James Suckling, praised Oregon Chardonnay for its minerality, its "laser-like acidity," citrus peel and herbal notes, and its clear sense of site. In that report, more than half of roughly two hundred Oregon Chardonnays reviewed scored ninety-three points or higher, by that critic's judgment.

Growers have planted more of it. In the Willamette Valley, Chardonnay acreage doubled between 2014 and 2025. Statewide it covers about seven percent of Oregon's vineyards, a little over three thousand acres in 2025.

Cabernet Sauvignon is a different story, and a number called growing degree days explains it. Growing degree days measure how much useful warmth a season gives a vine. For each day from April first to October thirty-first, you take the day's average temperature in Fahrenheit and count how many degrees it ran above fifty, the point below which vines barely grow. Add up every day of the season and you get the total. Cabernet Sauvignon ripens best with about three thousand to three thousand five hundred growing degree days or more. The Willamette Valley, a cool climate, typically gathers about nineteen hundred to twenty-three hundred. McMinnville's figure is about two thousand two hundred eighty-five, and the warm 2023 season reached around twenty-five hundred. Even a hot year in the valley falls about five hundred degree days short of the bottom of Cabernet's range. Pinot noir and Chardonnay, both early ripeners, fit that budget. Cabernet would run out of season, and you would taste the result as green pepper and hard tannin.

So Oregon grows its Cabernet Sauvignon in warmer, drier places east of the Cascades and to the south. In 2023, the climate researcher Dr. Greg Jones reported totals near three thousand three hundred growing degree days in the Umpqua Valley, about three thousand four hundred in the Columbia Gorge and Walla Walla, and about three thousand six hundred in the Rogue Valley. The Rogue and Applegate valleys in southern Oregon and the Walla Walla Valley, which straddles the Washington line, are where Oregon's Cabernet ripens.

Ricochet's Pinot blanc and the cellar choices behind it

Ricochet Wine Co., the show's home winery in McMinnville, does not make a Chardonnay or a Cabernet among the wines it has described. But it does make a white that shows nearly every cellar choice this lesson just taught: its 2023 Pinot blanc.

Pinot blanc is part of the Pinot family. It is a color mutation of Pinot noir, the kind of change we talked about in the last lesson, so it is a close relative of Chardonnay's own parent. Ricochet buys the grapes from Yamhill Valley Vineyards, which sits in the McMinnville appellation. That appellation belongs to the grower's vineyard, not to the winery, which is simply in the town of McMinnville.

Ricochet's technical sheet describes the 2023 Pinot blanc this way. The grapes were pressed as whole clusters, meaning the bunches went into the press uncrushed, which gives a gentle, clean juice. The juice was then fermented in French oak barrels, and the wine went through full malolactic conversion. Those are two of the four levers that turn Chardonnay rich and round. Barrel fermentation brings the slow air through the wood that rounds a wine's texture, and full malolactic conversion turns sharp malic acid into softer lactic acid and can bring a buttery note. Now set that against what you know of the valley: cool-climate fruit that holds its acid. That is the same balance the Willamette Chardonnay producers above are reaching for, fresh fruit from a cool site with texture added in the cellar. In the Pinot blanc you can taste for both halves at once, the acid from the place and the creaminess from the cellar.

There is a second lesson in Ricochet's grape list, about how a winery without its own vineyards decides what to make. A small winery that buys its grapes works through relationships with growers, usually under contracts that set which rows, which variety and roughly how much fruit it will take. That means it can only make what its growers can grow well. A grower in the cool Willamette Valley can supply Pinot noir, Pinot blanc, Chardonnay or Gamay. None of them can reliably ripen Cabernet. So a winery that wants warm-climate grapes goes where the heat is.

Ricochet's own sources show exactly that. Its Pinot noir, Pinot blanc and Gamay come from Willamette Valley growers. Its Syrah, Tempranillo and its white blend of Marsanne, Roussanne and Viognier, called MRV, come from Les Collines Vineyard in Walla Walla, Washington, in the same warm Walla Walla country that reached about three thousand four hundred growing degree days in 2023. The grapes that need more heat come from the place that has it. The growing degree day math you just heard turns up directly in where one McMinnville winery buys its fruit.

The valley this November

Out in the valley, harvest is in and the new wines are in tank and barrel. Final tonnage for 2026 and critics' verdicts on the vintage have not yet been reported, so the early view from a single producer, which we covered when picking ended, is still the latest word on quality.

The business side brought a number worth understanding. On November twelfth and thirteenth, Willamette Valley Vineyards, a publicly traded winery in the valley, reported its results for the third quarter of 2026. Sales rose six point six percent from a year earlier, to eight point nine million dollars. It still posted a net loss for the quarter of about one point oh five million dollars, and it reported inventory of about thirty-two point eight million dollars. That inventory figure teaches something about how wine works as a business. A winery pays for grapes, barrels and labor now, then holds the wine for months or years before it sells. All that waiting wine sits on the books as inventory, money spent that has not yet come back. A winery can grow its sales and still lose money in a quarter while it carries that stock.

On the rules side, there were no new federal labeling rules and no changes to the valley's appellations in the past few weeks.

And the valley's biggest weekend of the season is close. Wine Country Thanksgiving, when participating wineries across the Willamette Valley open their doors, runs November twenty-first through twenty-third, and again from November twenty-sixth through thirtieth. As with any day of winery visits, plan it around a spittoon or a designated driver.

The same weekend brings something at the show's home winery. Ricochet belongs to a friend of the show, and its Indie Wine Mixer, called A Very Indie Thanksgiving, runs November twenty-first and twenty-second. Whether you go that weekend or another day, visit Ricochet in McMinnville, booked through ricochetwine.com, and ask to taste the Pinot blanc beside one of its other whites. With small pours, a spittoon or a designated driver, check each glass for three things: how much your mouth waters, how creamy it feels, and whether you can find any sign of the barrel. Next come Syrah and Grenache, two grapes of warmer country.

Want a book of your own?

Gnothi wrote and narrated this chapter. Name a subject and it writes you a course, or a story that teaches it, one chapter at a time, delivered to your podcast app.

Get started free